52 pages • 1 hour read
Alex AsterA modern alternative to SparkNotes and CliffsNotes, SuperSummary offers high-quality Study Guides with detailed chapter summaries and analysis of major themes, characters, and more.
As Isla prepares for the ceremony, she thinks that the wedding is a mistake. She attempts to banish thoughts of Oro as well as memories of her first marriage to Grim. To make the ceremony special for Isla, Grim sends Astria to escort Isla, holds the wedding in her beloved greenhouse, and includes Wildlings among the guests. Eta is the officiant, and she persuades some of Grim’s subjects to accept the marriage by declaring it a “union that was fated” (179). As part of the ceremony, Isla clasps a necklace around Grim’s neck that cannot be removed until his death. As the couple dances together, Isla feels both “radiantly happy and horribly disappointed in herself” (180). Isla realizes that she still loves Grim even though she hasn’t forgiven him.
During the celebration, a guard whispers urgent news to Grim. To keep the guests from panicking, Isla initiates a passionate kiss with Grim. He teleports them away, making it seem that they have retired to their bedchamber. In actuality, Grim takes them to the graveyard where the soldiers who died in the recent war were buried. Someone dug up the graves. Isla sees a serpent among the dirt and remembers Eta’s warning. Poppy and Terra are the only Wildlings who weren’t invited to the wedding. Isla accuses them of desecrating the graves and conspiring against her, and she demands that Grim imprison them.
Isla asks the blacksmith for a way to find her lost ring. He mentions that the dangerous lost art of skyres may offer a solution but urges her not to seek out this destructive power. Recalling that Aurora had markings on her skin, Isla uses the quill to confirm that the Starling knows how to draw skyres. Aurora offers to teach Isla because she wants redemption. When Isla meets up with Sairsha that night, the women bond over their mutual desire for redemption. Sairsha gives Isla a wine that makes her fall unconscious.
When she awakens beside a river, Isla sees Sairsha with all the regulars from the bar gathered around her, wearing hooded cloaks and swords. They are prophet-followers who believe that Isla is destined to save the world or destroy it. Sairsha says that their deaths at her hands will be an honor and that killing them is “the part [Isla] must play” (202). The prophet-followers attack Isla, forcing her to kill them all. Sairsha uses a rare form of magic to animate her shadow, and she is the last prophet-follower to fall.
Isla has the blacksmith remove the shademade bracelets because she believes she could have spared Sairsha and the prophet-followers if she’d had access to her powers. During a visit to the castle’s library, she bonds with Astria over their mutual enjoyment of romances, and the general tells Isla about her late father’s love of maps. Like his daughter, he was “desperate to see outside the world he had been born into” (212). Isla goes to her father’s castle and discovers a map of an uninhabited island to the west of Nightshade named Isla.
Isla pockets the map and reflects on how her parents’ love story parallels her marriage with Grim. Both are unions between a Wildling woman and a Nightshade man who decided to put aside their differences. Isla uses her starstick to teleport to the island of Isla. The landmass teems with plant and animal life, but it’s uninhabited by people, allowing Isla to refamiliarize herself with her powers without fear of hurting anyone. She teleports baskets of fruit from the island to the doorsteps of hungry Nightshade villagers.
Isla returns to her room in Grim’s castle that night, and a group of black-speckled green snakes lead her to a mirror that shows her a reflection of herself entwined with serpents. The snakes vanish as if they were a hallucination. The stormfinch’s song announces the approach of another storm, and Grim and Isla evacuate a remote village. Isla tries to capture a piece of the tempest in the diamond ring Azul returned to her, but tornadoes full of shademade fragments force her to take shelter until the storm passes. After a week of storms, Isla grows desperate and asks Aurora to teach her how to draw skyres.
Aurora teaches Isla how to write skyres using shademade metal. Using Aurora’s quill, she draws a marking on her arm that should allow her to control her powers with precision. The process is agonizing, but she thinks this is her best hope of saving lives. Isla uses her Nightshade powers to make the skyre invisible.
Grim confesses that he never loved anyone before Isla and thought that he was incapable of such feelings. He explains that every Nightshade ruler before him, including his father, had many children and killed them to increase their power. Although Isla knows that she will never stop loving Oro, she accepts that she loves Grim unconditionally. She changes into her first wedding dress and tells him, “I’m ready to try again. To be your wife. Truly” (231). He kneels before her, sheds joyful tears, and promises that they will be happy together. The couple relives their original passionate wedding night.
Grim brings Isla to the winter palace in Nightshade’s perpetually snowy northern region. He spent his childhood there, and he was happy because his father never visited. He brings her to a charming village with a “roof like folded pieces of parchment” and chimneys sprouting smoke “like steam from tea” (240). As a child, Grim was forbidden from sweets, games, and anything else that his father deemed opposed to the purpose of molding him into a ruthless warrior and ruler. The young Grim would use his teleportation power to steal licorice from the sweet shop and watch the village children play, and he reimbursed the shopkeeper with a massive pile of coins one day. At Isla’s prompting, they visit the village’s stores, purchasing licorice and warm, casual clothes. Isla and Grim trade stories from their childhoods.
Grim shows Isla the hedge maze beyond the winter palace’s gardens. No one can use their powers within the labyrinth because Cronan, the first Nightshade ruler, is buried at its center in a shademade coffin. They return to the castle and have sex in a library. After Grim leaves to attend to his royal duties, Isla locates a book on skyres with Aurora’s help. That evening, Isla and Grim enjoy a romantic dinner in the village.
To help Isla become more comfortable using her power, Grim spars with her. She continues to research skyres and learns that the most powerful markings must be formed with bones rather than blood. She intends to take one of Cronan’s bones, but she’s attacked by monsters when she enters the labyrinth. Losing blood, she staggers to the coffin only to discover that it’s empty. Isla faints as she exits the maze, and Grim catches her. Isla theorizes that Cronan’s bones created the portal because he had the ability to teleport. The labyrinth’s power-blocking properties kept Grim from finding the portal despite his thorough searches. Grim sees the skyre on Isla’s arm and asks what it is.
In the novel’s third section, romantic elements figure prominently as Isla falls back in love with Grim. These chapters include a wedding ceremony, a dance, flirtatious banter, and passionate sexual encounters. However, Aster subverts romantic conventions in that this is Isla and Grim’s second marriage, the ceremony occurs in the middle of the book rather than providing a happy ending, and the wedding takes place for reasons other than romance: as a diversion meant to soothe their subjects and appease Isla’s opponents.
The complicated circumstances around Grim and Isla’s second marriage develop the theme of The Tension Between Love and Duty. Isla’s still in love with Oro, and she agrees to marry Grim largely to help Oro move on so that she won’t pose a danger to him any longer—embracing a duty of care even at the expense of her romantic desires. Despite this, the protagonist’s relationship with Grim fundamentally changes after the wedding. Isla goes from seeing him as her enemy to loving him as her husband: “If she was going to save Nightshade, and change her fate, she needed to work with Grim—not against him” (230). After she gives herself permission to embrace her love for Grim—believing that this love aligns more closely with her duties toward the people of Lightlark—she hopes that her “happy ending” will be with him (232). Their first sexual encounter in this book is a replay of their first wedding night, emphasizing that the couple is reclaiming what they once shared. In addition to the characters’ restored physical intimacy, they gain new levels of trust and honesty when she tells him about the skyres, “grateful to be burning at least some of the secrets between them” (270). As her marriage to Grim continues, Isla hopes to leave behind the secrecy and guilt that have characterized much of her romantic life.
Aster uses Sairsha’s character to explore The Uncertain Existence of Free Will. As one of the prophet’s followers, Sairsha provides more exposition about the prophecies: “He said that at the end of the world, a girl will be born from life and death. The girl will either destroy the world … or save it” (202). This new prophecy offers hope that Isla’s legacy may bring redemption rather than devastation. Sairsha’s character also shows Isla how Isla’s destiny impacts every facet of her life, further developing the theme. Unbeknownst to Isla, their connection was always rooted in Sairsha’s belief that Isla is the world’s destined savior. Sairsha is the closest thing Isla has to a friend, which makes the plot twist that she is a prophet-follower more shocking and tragic. Sairsha’s death reaffirms Isla’s fear that she’s destined to bring death and destruction wherever she goes, but she clings to her deceased friend’s claim that trying to make a difference matters, such as when she brings fruit to the hungry villagers. Sairsha’s shadow magic proves vital during the novel’s climax, vindicating her faith in Isla and her decision to sacrifice herself.
Grim, Sairsha, and Isla’s father support her on The Journey of Self-Acceptance. Her dangerous, ruthless aspects make her similar to her husband: “[H]e was the only one who hadn’t made her feel shame for who and what she was” (184). Grim’s unconditional love helps her to embrace the parts of herself that she used to reject as monstrous. The deaths of Sairsha and the prophet-followers mark a turning point for this theme. After deciding that she is done “pretending to be powerless” (207), Isla removes the bracelets that prevented her from using her magic. In addition, learning more about her parents and uncovering the secret island that shares her name grants her a greater understanding of herself and helps her feel safe reclaiming her power.