51 pages • 1 hour read
Kate DiCamilloA modern alternative to SparkNotes and CliffsNotes, SuperSummary offers high-quality Study Guides with detailed chapter summaries and analysis of major themes, characters, and more.
Jack leads Beatryce and Answelica to the dark woods, where he tells Beatryce he needs her and places her hand on Answelica’s head. These things bring Beatryce out of her daze, and the children climb a tree while Answelica guards them from below. When Jack asks Beatryce to hold the soldier’s sword so they can climb higher, Beatryce refuses, saying, “I will not hold that sword” […] do not ask me again” (106). Footsteps approach, and a male voice sings to Answelica, asking her to come with them. The next thing Jack and Beatryce hear is Answelica headbutting the man and the man laughing.
The man knows Jack and Beatryce are in the tree because they smell like fear. Jack makes up a story about them having a message for the king, which the man doesn’t believe. Answelica doesn’t attack the man again, which Beatryce recognizes as a sign of trust. She climbs down from the tree, and though Jack doesn’t trust the man, he follows because somehow “where Beatryce went, he must go” (114).
Beatryce hates the sword because she can feel that it knows something about her past. The man no longer has a name, but he tells the children to call him Cannoc. Beatryce decides to trust him because she liked his song about Answelica and “because he laughed so well” (117). This makes her realize she trusts others in her life for strange reasons, such as Jack for his whistle and Answelica for her soft ear, and she doesn’t know how to feel about this.
At the monastery, the king’s soldiers question Edik, who admits to finding Beatryce. Long ago, Edik spoke the prophecy about a girl unseating a king and bringing about change, which he now knows to be about Beatryce. After gathering supplies, he goes to the village, where the innkeeper’s wife claims she knows nothing while pointing in the direction she saw the group enter the dark woods. Edik doesn’t know if he’ll find Beatryce, but he goes after her, thinking, “It mattered that he should look for her, that he should never give up searching for her” (124).
Beatryce dreams of the seahorse and remembers more details, including her tutor, her brothers, and the warm sunlight reflecting off of her auburn hair. Soldiers burst into the room, killing her tutor and brothers, and Beatryce pretends to be dead to save her life. The soldier announces that his task is complete, and Beatryce recognizes him as “the man in the dark room at the inn” (131). Someone shouts her name, and she wakes.
Beatryce starts to cry, sobbing so much that she feels “she would drown in her own tears” (133). She remembers everything about the attack, but she does not know what became of her mother. At the mention of her mother, she remembers her true identity, Beatryce of Abelard, and that the king wants her dead.
Cannoc reveals he was once king but left the castle one day and never went back. Ever since, he’s felt freer than he ever did with the crown on his head and all the power of the king’s station. When Jack asks if anyone searched for him, Cannoc says that no one looks for a king. Rather, those left behind “start to scheme and calculate about how to take the crown for themselves” (138). With her memory restored, Beatryce will bring the sword that killed her family back to the king and force him to account for his actions.
In the castle dungeon, the king’s counselor tells Beatryce’s mother about Beatryce’s prophecy to unseat the king and bring about change, adding that he used the king’s prophecy to benefit himself and muses, “[W]hy not bend another to my ends?” (143).
Jack tries to talk Beatryce out of confronting the king, but Beatryce won’t relent. Beatryce remembers two tutors she had. The first was an oily man who wanted to suppress her curiosity and intellect. The second showed her amazing things in the world and sky. Beatryce thinks of how much learning opened her mind and again resolves to make the king account for his deeds: “But first, I will teach Jack Dory his letters” (153).
As promised, Beatryce teaches Jack the alphabet, and with every letter he learns, Jack feels as if “a door pushed open inside of him” (156).
Beatryce dreams of her castle home, where a strange bird tells her that someone has taken her mother. Before Beatryce can learn who, she wakes feeling cold. She wants her mother and Edik, and she concludes, “There are too many people to miss” (159).
In the dark woods, Edik realizes he is not afraid of the man with the knife. Edik thinks of Beatryce, Answelica, and the prophecy, “glad to have been a part of the story” (162). The man orders Edik to kneel and close his eyes. Edik does, and soon, he hears laughter. After a moment, the man with the knife is gone, and Cannoc arrives, laughing and asking Edik to come with him.
The group discusses the prophecy and the future. Cannoc wonders if the change will make Beatryce a queen, to which Beatryce says she doesn’t want to be a queen and wants “only to find my mother and to look the king in the eye and hear him say what he has done” (169). Jack and Edik remind her of the promises she made them (teaching Jack to read and writing the mermaid’s story for Edik).
As the others sleep, Beatryce lies awake thinking of everything she lost, the prophecy, and what she must do to make things right. Though she doesn’t like it, she needs to face the king first and fulfill her promises to Jack and Edik later if she has the opportunity. With Answelica at her side, she steps out into the starlit night, which she admires for a moment before “the stars disappeared, and the world became nothing but darkness” (174).
Answelica rushes back into the tree and wakes Jack, who grabs the soldier’s sword and hurries outside, only to find Beatryce gone. Edik and Cannoc join him, and there is a moment of despair before Jack looks into Answelica’s eyes and sees the truth: “There is no time to waste. We must go to the castle of the king” (177).
Wrapped in a foul-smelling cloth, Beatryce rides on a horse with her captor. In the past, there was always someone to help her through the dark times, but now, she only has herself, which reminds her of a storybook she read in which a king-turned-wolf could only become human again once he believed in who he was. With this, Beatryce realizes she is beloved by people and a goat and that they will come find her because “we shall all, in the end, be led to where we belong. We shall all, in the end, find our way home” (185).
Cannoc spends the rest of the night teaching Jack how to fight with the sword, and the group sets out after Beatryce at dawn. Armed with his new weapon and knowledge, Jack focuses on the robber who killed his parents and whoever took Beatryce, thinking that “Jack Dory and his sword would like to meet them all” (187).
Jack and Beatryce’s quest group is rounded out by Cannoc (the former king) and Edik, whose character arc leads him toward Coping with Trauma and allows him to take risks he was too afraid to take previously. Beatryce and Jack have different ideas of trust when it comes to letting others into their group, and this reflects the different ways of Being True to Oneself. Beatryce relies on Answelica and her gut feelings to determine whether she should trust someone. Answelica is very protective of Beatryce, and while she initially headbutts Cannoc, she does so because tensions are high, and her attitude is to protect first and ask questions later. Once Answelica understands Cannoc, she trusts him immediately, which helps Beatryce also to trust him quickly. In Chapter 26, Beatryce recounts her reasons for trusting people, finding them not what she expected. She trusts based on unusual things like enjoying songs and the softness of ears, not realizing that these things are physical manifestations of deeper emotions. Cannoc’s song is carefree and light, and Beatryce trusts the song because it means that Cannoc is good because no one evil could be so joyous or fun. She trusts Jack’s whistling because it shows that he’s willing to be there for her, as evidenced by how she heard him outside the inn in Chapter 21. The softness of Answelica’s ear calls to comfort. Beatryce clung to the ear when she had nothing else, and its warmth, coupled with the warmth of the creature who offered it, convince her she can trust Answelica.
Cannoc’s attitude toward his former role as king and toward kings in general shows how power corrupts. Cannoc disliked the power he held because it came with stress and a feeling of being weighed-down. As a result, the power didn’t corrupt him, because he didn’t want more than he had, knowing that it would come with even more stress and weight. Cannoc was able to walk away from a life he hated to preserve his sense of self, the ultimate sign of Being True to Oneself. Cannoc’s observation that kings want to keep being kings speaks to how many respond to the burden of power. Though it comes with stress, it also affords luxuries and an intoxicating feeling of superiority. These factors combine to create a sense that losing the kingship will mean losing everything and that the only way to keep from losing everything is to amass more power. Thus, corruption is not so dissimilar from desperation. The current king, who was installed by the current counselor, fears losing his position because he worked hard to make something of himself after being a nobody. Thus, his desperation corrupts the good person he may have once been into someone willing to have children killed to ensure he won’t lose what he’s achieved.
These chapters delve into Destiny Is a Choice, the novel’s third major theme. Beatryce gains an understanding of the prophecy that brought about the current king and the prophecy about how she will unseat him and bring change. Though she doesn’t yet realize it, she has no use for prophecy. Rather, she believes that following the prophecy will also get her what she wants—to be reunited with her mother and to ensure the king atones for his actions. There are any number of ways she could accomplish these goals, but she is constricted by the emphasis placed on the importance of prophecy. Thus, she believes she must march to the castle and confront the king, which leads to her capture at the end of Part 4. Her decision and subsequent capture illustrate the downsides of believing that fate controls everything. If Beatryce hadn’t gotten so caught up in her fate and the fate of the kingdom, she wouldn’t have rushed into action and likely wouldn’t have been captured. Because she is a well-written protagonist, she finds a way to make her disadvantage work in her favor, but not relying on fate would have let her avoid unpleasantness, both for herself and for her worried friends.
Chapter 41 is a major moment in Beatryce’s character development. As discussed in earlier analysis, Beatryce does her best to deal with her past by Coping with Trauma because she recognizes that letting the darkness rule she isn’t helping her or anyone around her. Up until here, she has relied mainly on Answelica’s ear, but also Jack, Cannoc, and Edik, to help her through her darkest moments and bring her back to the light. Captured, she is deprived of all the trust and comfort she found in the group, and without them to rely on, she begins to trust herself, an element of the themes of Being True to Oneself and Destiny Is a Choice. This chapter also shows how stories from her past help Beatryce learn and grow. Beatryce comes to her conclusions about trust because she remembers a story that taught that exact lesson. Her ability to read gave her skills for navigating new situations, which explains why the king and others want to restrict reading to only the educated and those loyal to the king. If the stories are kept from the masses, they cannot learn the lessons within stories or be exposed to new ideas or people different from themselves.
By Kate DiCamillo