logo

50 pages 1 hour read

Brittney Morris

The Cost of Knowing

Fiction | Novel | YA | Published in 2021

A modern alternative to SparkNotes and CliffsNotes, SuperSummary offers high-quality Study Guides with detailed chapter summaries and analysis of major themes, characters, and more.

Themes

Fate Versus Free Will

In Brittney Morris’s magical realism novel, Alex’s psychic powers enmesh him in the conflict between fate and free will. At the beginning of the story, Alex feels powerless to oppose destiny. Whenever he tries to change what he sees in his visions, his attempts end in failure. As a result, he becomes defeated and resigned: “Better, and less humiliating, to just lie low and let fate happen” (6). However, Alex learns to exercise his free will and take a more active role in his life after he sees his brother’s burial. His fight against fate isn’t a direct attack. Knowing that his visions are immutable, he understands that he can’t prevent Isaiah’s death. Instead, he changes the narrative by rebuilding his relationship with Isaiah. He ensures that his little brother’s last days are filled with joy and purpose, and he becomes determined to break the curse: “[I]f nothing else happens before Isaiah dies, if I get nothing else right, if I can’t make up for years of not being there for him, I have to help him get rid of these visions” (97). Alex’s burning resolution to free himself and Isaiah from their visions forms a stark contrast with his earlier resignation.

By facing the fear that he feels toward Isaiah’s death, Alex finds liberation from his burdensome knowledge of fate. His new sense of clarity allows him to accept fear as a part of life while freeing himself of the constant anxiety his visions triggered. Just as he altered the course of his life by breaking the curse, Alex feels empowered to continue changing his narrative. He thought Scoop’s ice cream shop was doomed from the first chapter, but he sets the goal of buying the store in a few years in the final chapter. No longer beset by inalterable visions, Alex looks to the future with newfound hope: “I wonder where I’ll end up. What a privilege” (322). Alex transforms over the course of the novel as he breaks away from fate and reclaims his free will. Morris’s novel offers hope to people, especially Black youth, who feel as though their future is already decided for them.

The Pressure to Grow Up Too Soon

Due to a combination of personal and societal factors, Alex is under severe pressure to grow up too soon. At the start of the novel, Alex is so weighed down by grief, guilt, and dread that he feels much older than 16. He lost both of his parents at age 12, and he still blames himself for not being there for his best friend, Shaun, who died a year later. Adding to these past tragedies, Alex’s visions show him the imminent loss of his little brother. When Talia asks Alex to act like a teenager during their argument in Chapter 8, Alex thinks, “When you lose both your parents at twelve, your best friend at thirteen, and your little brother at sixteen, you don’t get to be sixteen. Not if you’re a man-in-training” (181). Alex’s personal losses and his belief that he must bear them like a “man-in-training” make him reluctant to rely on anyone, which complicates his relationships with others, including his girlfriend.

While some of the pressures Alex faces, such as his psychic abilities, are unique to his situation, many are societal forces that impact many young Black men. Much of the strain that Alex is under stems from the pressure to be a provider. The belief that he must be a man and that being a man means earning a paycheck is so ingrained in Alex that it “makes [him] physically ill to think […] that anyone, actually, would think [he’s] unreliable. Or that [he doesn’t] care about [his] job” (96). He feels personally responsible for whether his girlfriend’s family can evade eviction, a burden that no teenager should have to carry. In addition, police brutality and widespread racism present dangers to young people like Alex on a daily basis. The murder of the unnamed, unarmed  16-year-old Black boy in Alex’s neighborhood by his own neighbor emphasizes these dangers. During a conversation with Talia after the killing, Alex voices the constant pressure he’s under: “I don’t get to be sixteen, because people judge me like a twenty-year-old! I’ve got a job, I’ve got a car, I do okay in school, and when I come home, that shit is still staring me in the face” (181). As a young Black man, Alex is held to a level of maturity that his peers of other races are not. Alex knows that these double standards and prejudiced assumptions are unfair, but he also knows that meeting these unjust expectations is a matter of survival.

Over the course of the novel, Alex’s conversations with Talia and his time with Isaiah help him reclaim his youth. Prioritizing his little brother’s well-being over his job allows Alex to confront the pressure on him to be a provider, and he decides that it’s more important for a man to protect his family than earn a paycheck. At the concert, Alex remembers Talia asking him, “Can you just be sixteen with me?” (227). Her words encourage him to make some impulsive purchases purely for the joy they bring Isaiah. This action represents a moment when Alex takes the weight of the world off his shoulders. By the end of the novel, losing Isaiah helps Alex understand that he cannot keep everyone safe, and, moreover, that he is not a man but rather “a boy [who] shouldn’t have to try” to protect everyone (300). Through Alex’s story, Morris encourages young Black men to hold onto their youth and find joy in spite of the many factors that pressure them to grow up too soon.

The Importance of Brotherhood

Alex and Isaiah’s life-changing bond demonstrates the importance of brotherhood. The eventual strength of their relationship is all the more meaningful given how badly it has deteriorated by the time the novel begins. The distance between the brothers started when they lost their parents, widened after Shaun’s death, and is exacerbated by the strain of living with psychic abilities. The vision of Isaiah’s death inspires Alex to push through that distance and Isaiah’s initial defensiveness to rebuild their relationship. Soon, Alex realizes that they are united by the very things that once isolated them: “All this time, I’ve been enduring these visions in silence. Suffering alone. But I had company this whole time, just down the hall from my room. Isaiah’s had company” (88). One reason why the brothers’ relationship is so meaningful is that they understand each other in a way no one else can because they share the same losses and struggles.

Repairing their relationship allows the brothers to grow in ways that seemed impossible mere days ago. After withdrawing from the world for years, Alex and Isaiah reach out to one another and give each other someone to confide in. Isaiah helps his older brother process his complicated feelings around his visions, Talia, and Shaun. In return, Alex helps his little brother reclaim his joy and hope. Together, Alex and Isaiah find the strength to face their greatest fears and break the curse that has tormented their family for centuries. This experience brings them even closer. The brothers voice their love for each other for the first time when they reunite after the concert: “‘We did it, man,’ I say. ‘Yeah,’ he whispers, and then, after a long, deep breath, he says, ‘I love you, Alex’” (271). Thanks to Alex, Isaiah knows that he is loved and that he isn’t alone at the end of his life. The novel’s resolution shows that those last few days with Isaiah will have a permanent effect on Alex, as indelible as the word tattooed on his palm: “King, for me. King, for Isaiah. [….] To give me resolve where there could be regret, and courage where there could be fear” (322). In his final days, Isaiah taught Alex how to stop living with regret and to find hope for the future. The Rufus brothers offer a powerful example of the importance of brotherhood.

blurred text
blurred text
blurred text
blurred text

Related Titles

By Brittney Morris