31 pages • 1 hour read
Ursula K. Le GuinA modern alternative to SparkNotes and CliffsNotes, SuperSummary offers high-quality Study Guides with detailed chapter summaries and analysis of major themes, characters, and more.
Summary
Chapter Summaries & Analyses
Character Analysis
Themes
Symbols & Motifs
Important Quotes
Essay Topics
Tools
Davidson recites the story of the Smith Camp massacre into Major Muhamed’s recorder. He believes that Lyubov is behind the attacks on them, in alliance with the creechies. He also does not believe that Lyubov is dead, although that is what his people say. He wonders if the creechies actually killed the women or if they have them locked away somewhere. He speaks with a man named Juju over the radio. Juju says that there has been a formal truce and that Davidson’s agitations are making it harder for them all. Davidson says that he is going to liberate all the human slaves, and he doesn’t believe Juju’s protestations that the humans have been released. He feels sick when he thinks that the humans have been locked inside a reservation and are taking orders from the creechies.
He takes fifteen men up in a ship and bombs a creechie warren miles away in the forest. It sets the forest on fire, which is his true weapon. He is prepared to burn the entire forest planet before submitting to the creechies. Gosse gets on the radio during the bombing and tells Davidson he is crazy. There is no way to subdue 3 million creechies through bombing. Colonel Dongh tells Davidson via the radio that he is putting him in a difficult position: “‘The position of being forced to tell the natives here that we can’t assume any responsibility for your actions’” (164). He tells Davidson that if he doesn’t stop, it will be tantamount to suicide for him and the men with him.
Davidson continues to bomb, burn, and log the forest. After two weeks, he is satisfied that he has incinerated all the creechie warrens within walking distance. He wants to make a raid on the main creechie outpost and take the other four ships because his is running low on fuel. A guard shouts that they are under attack, and Davidson sees thousands of creechies running toward the camp. He makes it to his ship and takes off with his pilot, Aabi. He tells Aabi to circle for twenty minutes. Then they are going to drop back down and burn the thousands of creechies below, even if it means also killing some of their own men. A man named Post disagrees, as does Aabi, and Davidson knocks Post out with the butt of his gun and then orders Aabi to keep circling. He thinks, “The weak conspire against the strong, the strong man has to stand alone and look out for himself” (172).
When they get to where Java Camp is supposed to be, they can’t see anything from the air. There are no lights or burning buildings. Davidson suddenly feels groggy and realizes that the ship has crashed, although he does not know why. He cannot see or hear Aabi. He gets out and walks into the forest, trying to clear his head. Then he sees the creechies. He falls down and lies there but keeps watching them. There are at least twenty. He gets into the same position he was in when Selver got him down but then refused to kill him: Creechies are not allowed or able to kill someone who takes this specific defensive posture. One of the creechies steps forward and looks down at him. It is Selver.
Davidson gets to his feet and spits in Selver’s face. Selver spits back and then laughs before telling Davidson, “‘We’re both gods, you and I. You’re an insane one, and I’m not sure whether I’m sane or not. But we are gods’” (179). He says that Davidson gave him the gift of murder, and Selver will now in turn give him the gift of not killing: “‘I think we each find each other’s gift heavy to carry’” (179). The creechies are going to take Davidson to Rendlep and leave him there, which is what they do with their kind when they go mad. Selver says that it was Lyubov who has prevented them from killing each other.
Rendlep is called Dump Island, and the humans have left no trees there: “‘There’s nothing to kill on Rendlep. No trees, no people’” (180). Davidson tells him to kill him, but Selver says that as a god, Davidson must kill himself. They put a noose around his neck and lead him away.
When the great ship returns, Selver goes to meet the yumens who have come on it. He gives them a box that contains Lyubov’s work. He tells them that Lyubov understood the Athsheans better than any other yumen had and that “I’ll give you the work, if you’ll take it to the place he wished’” (183).
The Commander of the ship asks to speak with Selver and tells him that when he leaves, he will take all of the Terrans with him. Selver’s world will no longer be used as a colony. “‘Your world has been placed under the League Ban,’” he says, meaning that they will never return (185). But he believes that humans will come back within five generations. Selver says, “‘You decide matters all at once, your people. You say that none of you shall cut the trees in Athshe: and all of you stop. And yet you live in many places’” (185). He says that if a headwoman in his world gave an order, it would not be obeyed by all the people on the world at once.
The Commander says that he has heard that when Selver gave an order, it was indeed followed by everyone. “‘At that time I was a god,’” (186) says Selver. Lepennon tells Selver that he met Lyubov once. He says that Lyubov’s main work was the freedom of the colony and that “[y]ou, being his friend, will see that his death did not stop him from arriving at his goal, from finishing his journey” (186). He then asks Selver if there have been more killings, and Selver says no and that he did not kill Davidson. Then Lepennon asks if Athsheans have killed Athsheans.
Selver replies:
‘Sometimes a god comes […] He brings a new way to do a thing, or a new thing to be done. A new kind of singing, or a new kind of death. He brings this across the bridge between the dream-time and the world-time. When he has done this, it is done. You cannot take things that exist in the world and try to drive them back into the dream, to hold them inside the dream with walls and pretenses. That is insanity. There is no use pretending, now, that we do not know how to kill one another’ (188).
Lepennon says that while that is true, there is no reason to murder, and they must not pretend to have reasons to kill one another. He believes that after the humans leave, Athshea will return to the way it was.
Lyubov appears in Selver’s mind and says that he will be there on Athshea. Selver replies: “‘Maybe after I die people will be as they were before I was born, and before you came. But I do not think they will’” (188).
The climax of the novella is the fate of Davidson. After continuing to attack the settlements for two weeks, he crashes in his airship and is captured by Selver, who spares him once again. Their conversation shows that Selver has realized that he has more in common with Davidson than he would like: He compares them both to gods, putting them on the same level. They are now both purveyors of death, although Selver experiences no joy in killing. He finds Davidson, like most of the yumens, to be insane, which is the only explanation he can see for the need to murder. When he strands Davidson in the treeless area, rather than killing him, it is because he believes that Davidson is more likely to learn from the fear of banishment from his race than he would from dying.
Chapter 8 is dedicated to the departure of the yumens and Selver’s misgivings about the future of his people. He will have a world without the yumens, and the trees will survive and regrow. However, a dark door has opened in his world, and it cannot be closed. Selver does not pretend that there will not be more killing, and that some of the responsibility for all future murders among his people lies with him. The novel closes on a pessimistic note. Selver and his people, whatever else their prowess and evolution with dreaming might imply, are still human, and human nature—as demonstrated in the book—predictably leads to murder.
By Ursula K. Le Guin