logo

56 pages 1 hour read

John Irving

The World According To Garp

Fiction | Novel | Adult | Published in 1978

A modern alternative to SparkNotes and CliffsNotes, SuperSummary offers high-quality Study Guides with detailed chapter summaries and analysis of major themes, characters, and more.

Chapters 15-19Chapter Summaries & Analyses

Chapter 15 Summary: “The World According to Bensenhaver”

The first chapter of Garp’s next novel depicts a woman named Hope Standish feeding her three-year-old son when a stranger walks into her kitchen and threatens her. He holds a knife to Nicky’s throat, and Hope immediately becomes compliant. He forces her to her bedroom and makes her take off her clothes. He cuts the phone cord. A neighbor, Margot, enters the house in search of Hope, and Hope yells for her to take Nicky and run. Oren forces her into his turquoise pickup truck and ties her to the door with her bra. They actually drive past her husband’s office, and Dorsey Standish thinks idly about the unique truck.

Oren drives into the countryside until they arrive at his family’s pig farm. He consults with his relatives Raspberry and Weldon, deciding to switch out his turquoise truck for a less distinctive black truck. Hope tries to advocate for herself, and Oren punches her. He overpowers her and shoves her head down. They drive further into the countryside, and she decides to perform oral sex on him to hopefully prevent him from being able to vaginally rape her. Oren stops her after a few minutes and insists that he put on a condom to prevent himself from contracting her germs. He rapes her and tells her that he has also raped animals. She feels his pants and finds the knife that he held to her son’s throat.

Back at Hope’s home, Margot has called the police, and inspector Arden Bensenhaver assures Dorsey that he will get his wife back. Bensenhaver and a deputy set off in a helicopter, and since Margot told them about the turquoise truck, they immediately head to the Rath pig farm. Bensenhaver tells the Raths that sex crimes are punishable by castration. Frightened by this lie, Raspberry tells them that Oren “might” be in the black truck. The deputies learn that Oren is 16 or 17.

Hope is debating how to cut Oren to give her time to escape. She aims for the kidneys and stabs him until he dies. When he stops moving, she flees the car and thinks that she is caught in a tornado. The noise and motion are actually Bensenhaver’s helicopter. Bensenhaver is very kind to her. In a flashback, the reader learns that Bensenhaver’s wife was raped and murdered when she was pregnant. Bensenhaver disposes of the condom in the truck, not wanting Hope to face any allegation that this was consensual sex. They board the helicopter, and Hope vomits profusely. Bensenhaver worries that her husband will not be sympathetic.

Chapter 16 Summary: “The First Assassin”

John Wolf hates the first chapter, but Garp insists that he sell it to a magazine. Helen gives birth to a daughter named Jenny. Wolf sells the chapter to a magazine called Crotch Shots. Jenny actually approves of the novel since it shows the ramifications of lust.

In the novel, Dorsey is paranoid and hires Bensenhaver to protect his family. The family completely falls apart as Dorsey struggles to maintain control: Their second child dies, Hope has an affair, and Dorsey resents his wife. He tells Bensenhaver that there is a prowler in their neighborhood, hoping that Bensenhaver will catch Hope’s lover. Dorsey hides in his wife’s closet, and Bensenhaver, mistaking him for the intruder, shoots him. Bensenhaver is sent to an “old-age home for the criminally insane” (383). Hope and her children find happiness.

John Wolf still thinks the novel is terrible, but he is determined to see if he can make it a success. His secret litmus test is the publishing office’s cleaner, Jillsy, who dislikes reading. He pays her to read the novels that he’s unsure about, and he immediately regrets giving her The World According to Bensenhaver. To his surprise, Jillsy is completely engrossed in it. Wolf tells Garp that the book should be dedicated to Jillsy, and he sends it off to be published. Wolf takes advantage of Garp’s tragic backstory to market the novel, which he knows Garp will despise. Helen is suspicious about Jillsy’s real identity, assuming that she is a lover of Garp’s. Garp is convinced that he will die by suicide, believing it to be a proper writerly death.

Wolf advises the family to wait out the book’s release in Vienna, and as he drops them off at the airport, he gives Garp a copy of the book jacket hidden in multiple layers of envelopes to prevent him from seeing it immediately. Both Garp and Helen are deeply hurt by Wolf’s sensationalist tactic, especially since he chose a photo of Garp, Walt, and Duncan for the back cover. The family discusses a beach trip with young Walt, who called the undertow “the Under Toad” (408). Garp and Helen immediately seized this phrase to refer to anxiety.

In Vienna, the Under Toad is everywhere. Garp feels sad and nostalgic to see how the city has changed. John Wolf tries to filter the reviews of The World According to Bensenhaver that reach Garp. Some reviewers praise it as a feminist tract that shows the ramifications of “the peculiarly male neurotic pressure many women are made to suffer,” while others view the novel as a sensationalist celebration of violence against women (409).

Jenny is becoming involved with the New Hampshire gubernatorial race; the incumbent is a sexist man, and his opponent advocates for women’s rights. Garp panics when Duncan does not come home on time.

Roberta calls Garp very late at night, and he assumes it is about her love life. He is devastated to hear that his mother has been assassinated. Garp watches the murder on television. The family flies home.

Chapter 17 Summary: “The First Feminist Funeral, and Other Funerals”

Garp wants to go to his mother’s funeral, but Roberta tells him that no men are allowed at “the first feminist funeral” (419). Garp is angry because his mother did like being called a feminist. Helen worries because she is unable to reach her father. Roberta tells Garp that if he wants to go to the funeral, he’ll need to go in drag. Helen decides that she and the kids will go to Steering instead to try to find her father. Garp finally meets Jillsy, who tells him that his mother was worth “two or three of [him]” (424).

Many of the funeral attendees, inspired by Jenny’s trademark uniform, are wearing nurses’ uniforms with red hearts sewn on. Garp feels very conspicuous in the outfit that Roberta has chosen for him. Sally Devlin, the candidate at whose rally Jenny was murdered, gives a heartfelt speech that ends in tears. Garp pretends to be an Ellen Jamesian to avoid having to speak, but he is recognized by Pooh Percy, Cushie’s sister. Pooh is adamant that Garp killed her sister by “fuck[ing] [her] to death” and loudly outs him to the crowd (431). Even with Roberta trying to help him escape, the funeral attendees tackle and hurt Garp. A nurse named Dotty helps him into a cab. The cab driver makes fun of Sally’s speeches and Garp threatens him. At the airport, Garp has trouble checking in because he is still in drag.

On the plane, Garp is hit on by his male seatmate, and Garp feels “a peculiar kind of unfairness overwhelm him” (435). Garp threatens the man, who retreats. A young woman takes his seat. She hands him a note, and he immediately assumes she is an Ellen Jamesian. However, she is the actual Ellen James. She tells him that she is a huge fan of The World According to Bensenhaver. After her parents’ deaths, she set off to meet Jenny. Now that Jenny is dead too, she does not know where to go. Garp invites her to come home with him and stay with his family.

When he arrives home, Garp is surprised to see Dean Bodger in his living room. Ernie had a heart attack while reading Crotch Shots; upon finding his friend’s body, Dean hid the magazine so that Helen would not know what her father was doing when he died. Ellen James quickly ingratiates herself with the family.

Fat Stew died the same day as Ernie, and their funerals take place in the school chapel on the same day. Garp heads to the chapel early to check on the arrangements, but because there are so few people in attendance, he is asked to be a pallbearer. Conscious of Pooh’s new hatred of him, he pretends to be someone else. Garp decides that he wants to buy the Steering house.

Chapter 18 Summary: “Habits of the Under Toad”

Helen is invited to teach English at Steering but still resents that they did not allow her to attend as a student. Garp volunteers to coach wrestling for free. Helen knows that he is avoiding writing because it makes him reflect on his own life too much.

Garp and Helen adjust to their new life at Steering. Duncan joins the swim team. Ellen becomes like an older sister to him, and they write screenplays and make movies together. Jenny left Garp in charge of her estate, and he starts planning the Fields Foundation, an organization devoted to helping women find sanctuary and education. Roberta becomes the in-residence administrator of the foundation. Garp and Roberta review the applications from women who have applied for grants. One of the applications is submitted by Mrs. Truckenmiller, the widow of the man who assassinated Jenny. Her husband was physically abusive to her and her children, and after she read A Sexual Suspect and felt empowered to leave him, he blamed feminism for the end of his marriage. John Wolf wants to approve her application. Roberta thinks she is a sex worker. Garp decides to go meet Mrs. Truckenmiller and evaluate her character for himself.

More Ellen Jamesians show up to Dog’s Head Harbor, annoying Garp. He wants to ban them from the house since he views them as the product of the same extremism that killed his mother. Garp and the Ellen Jamesians continue to loathe each other.

Garp is enthusiastic about Ellen’s writing, especially her autobiographical work. He encourages John Wolf to publish it. Garp travels to New Hampshire to meet Mrs. Truckenmiller. He gets a haircut from Harriet and meets her brother Dickie. Dickie confesses that he shot Kenny Truckenmiller because “[h]e just got sick about women. He got sick for good. You could tell he wasn’t ever going to get over it” (473).

Ellen’s essay is published and invites considerable controversy. Garp writes an essay in her defense and then publishes a poem about condoms, “man’s device to spare himself and others the consequences of his lust” (476). Garp finds solace in his friendship with Roberta.

One morning, Garp is jogging alone when a car attempts to hit him. The car crashes, killing the driver, an Ellen Jamesian. The Society distances itself from the driver but suggests that Garp had it coming to him. Despite this scare, Garp goes to his public reading and is touched when Duncan presents his illustrations for “The Pension Grillparzer.” He feels motivated to start writing again. Garp starts a novel called My Father’s Illusions.

Chapter 19 Summary: “Life After Garp”

One day in February, Garp invites Roberta to wrestling practice and then spends the morning writing. He has lunch with Donald Whitcomb, who becomes Garp’s biographer. Helen joins him at wrestling practice. Garp is surprised to see a nurse enter the wrestling room and then realizes that she’s wearing a Jenny Fields costume, not a real nursing outfit. Pooh Percy shoots Garp, who dies in Helen’s arms. He is 33 years old.

After his death, his books become more popular. Helen considers that his death ended up being a kind of suicide after all. The Fletchers stay married but die in a plane crash. Helen has many lovers but never remarries. Ellen James becomes a poet and drowns while swimming. Dean Bodger dies while watching wrestling. Mrs. Ralph becomes a tenured English professor and befriends Helen. Pooh Percy is institutionalized. Duncan becomes an artist. John Wolf and Roberta have a romantic relationship. Duncan loses his arm in an accident, and his sister and Roberta take care of him. Roberta enlists a trans friend to take care of Duncan’s apartment, and soon the two are exchanging romantic letters. Roberta dies suddenly. Duncan dies by choking on an olive. Michael Milton tries to write a biography of Garp. Jenny Garp becomes a brilliant nurse and is determined to keep her father’s and grandmother’s literary legacies alive. 

Chapters 15-19 Analysis

The embedded narrative of The World According to Bensenhaver is intended as Garp’s strongest piece of writing; once again, Garp’s fiction acts as a vehicle for him to reconcile tension and confront anxiety. Several instances of parallelism within The World According to Bensenhaver bear similarities to things Garp has witnessed. He loathes claiming autobiographical influences in the marketing of his novel but cannot confirm the extent to which he consciously employed these autobiographical influences. After Hope kills Oren and flees from his truck, a passerby observes, “The bloody, praying woman, naked and caked with grit, took no notice of him driving past her. The driver had a vision of an angel on a trip back from hell” (372). Hope’s exposed appearance is bolstered by the description of her as “an angel on a trip back from hell,” and her sense of helpless isolation evokes the earlier description of the raped 10-year-old wandering in the park. Garp is astounded by the strength of both Hope and the girl he encounters, and while both incidents serve to confirm his conviction that men’s lustful ways are inherently problematic, he also sees these incidents as confirmation that women are always already victimized because they are better equipped to handle being victimized—Garp perceives women as natural victims rather than as people who are victimized by external forces, including himself.

Though he would vocally pronounce himself a forward-thinking man, Garp still promotes simplistic and binary views of gender. Garp does not try to change himself or the men around him, citing a different kind of male impotence as justification for why this would be a fruitless effort; he believes men are powerless to change. Like Garp, Hope’s husband and Bensenhaver are very conscious of the depths of men’s potential for violence and depravity, but this awareness and dedication to constant vigilance ruins their lives.

At this point in the narrative, the ramifications of Garp’s perpetual anxiety are laid bare. “In Garp’s work, guilt always abounds,” but he does little to fix the causes of this guilt (382). Garp is so frequently preoccupied with the problems that cause him to feel guilty that he fails to pursue a solution. His guilt frequently manifests as performative; throughout his life, guilt, love, and anxiety work together, but not always productively. Just because he is constantly pondering a problem does not mean that he is actively working to fix it. He believes himself to be superior because he is conscious of some flaws, but he does not try to improve himself. When Garp is wearing women’s clothing on the plane and a stranger continues to hit on him, Garp is deeply offended, but does not use this experience as an opportunity to reflect on how he has treated women.

The last chapter offers tense foreshadowing of Garp’s death; the structure of the chapter is very similar to the structure of the first chapter in which Jenny’s arrest is revealed first and the events leading to her arrest follow. The parallels between the deaths of Jenny and Garp confirm Garp’s anxiety about the Ellen Jamesians and other radical factions of feminism. Jenny is murdered by a misogynist who refuses to take responsibility for his own actions and blames feminism for his failed marriage; Jenny is merely a convenient outlet for this rage. Garp is murdered by a misandrist Ellen Jamesian who cannot accept the actual circumstances of her sister’s death and mistakenly assumes that Garp’s lust caused Cushie to die. Irving creates parallels between the two examples of extremism. Both examples are easily persuaded that violence is the only solution because neither version is willing to change their perspective or try to learn from someone who does not just corroborate their existing beliefs.

Most of the novel vacillates between offering progressive support of second-wave feminism and offering critiques of it. The parallel deaths of Jenny and Garp suggest that second-wave feminism is doomed to be ostracized as just another extreme political movement if its practitioners think that the ends justify the means. Just as Jenny committed rape against Garp’s father to become pregnant and lead an independent life as a single mother, so too do the Ellen Jamesians advocate for the attempted assassination of Garp; Irving’s narrative argues that the ends cannot justify the means if the means of pursued equality must include such violence.

blurred text
blurred text
blurred text
blurred text