logo

60 pages 2 hours read

Jon Kabat-Zinn

Wherever You Go, There You Are: Mindfulness Meditation in Everyday Life

Nonfiction | Book | Adult | Published in 1994

A modern alternative to SparkNotes and CliffsNotes, SuperSummary offers high-quality Study Guides with detailed chapter summaries and analysis of major themes, characters, and more.

Part 3, Chapter 59-AfterwordChapter Summaries & Analyses

Part 3: “In the Spirit of Mindfulness”

Part 3, Chapter 59 Summary: “Not Harming - Ahimsa”

A new concept is introduced: ahimsa, or not causing harm. A commitment of all people to avoid doing harm to themselves and to others would result in a calmer, safer, and less violent world. This commitment can be undertaken at any moment in life. One may need to draw on it in their own self-talk if they find themself talking behind other people’s backs or if they are causing other people pain or grief. Harming or hurting comes from a root of fear; when fear doesn’t cloud one’s view, one can act with gentleness and kindness.

Part 3, Chapter 60 Summary: “Karma”

Karma acknowledges that all things have antecedents. A person’s karma refers to their impact on the world around them. Negative impulses and behaviors will have negative consequences. We are locked into behavior patterns by tendencies of thought, speech, and action. These tendencies result in further similar tendencies. Mindfulness allows one to make actionable changes to their karma, as they can watch their impulses and consider whether they feel authentic to them.

Without mindfulness, we are propelled forward thoughtlessly and continue to enact old patterns. Mindlessness imprisons us in hurt and anger. We react and blame, rather than acting with forethought and authenticity borne from a moment-to-moment knowledge of ourselves.

Part 3, Chapter 61 Summary: “Wholeness and Oneness”

Being in touch with our whole selves makes us feel one with the world. Merging with our breath helps us to merge with the universe. Finding our intrinsic wholeness makes us feel open and receptive and at one with the balance and harmony of the greater universe.

Part 3, Chapter 62 Summary: “Eachness and Suchness”

Unity among all things doesn’t mean sameness among all things. It is the inherent diversity of all things that makes the world so wondrous.

Part 3, Chapter 63 Summary: “What Is This?”

Inquiry into big and important questions of why we are here, what our purpose is, and what it means to be us should be continually examined in the process of living mindfully. However, Kabat-Zinn clarifies that extracting quick answers to these questions is not necessary or realistic. Through asking them over time, though, we might move closer to an understanding of them.

It is important to acknowledge the existence of disharmony within us. From that point, one can listen mindfully to the direction of their thoughts as they ponder the question.

Part 3, Chapter 64 Summary: “Selfing”

We consider all things through the frame of reference of ourselves, although who we are is a construction of multiple labels and identities that are constantly in flux. According to Kabat-Zinn, the deeper we descend into asking questions about ourselves, the more we realize that we don’t know who we truly are. We seek love, admiration, material possessions, and external validation to bolster our idea of who we are. Despite all of this, though, we might still have no firm idea of who we are and no sense of internal stability.

Kabat-Zinn suggests, in line with Buddhist philosophy, that we should stop attempting so hard to define ourselves, a process called “selfing,” and simply enjoy the being. This allows one to see things as they are without distortions. Accepting the elusive nature of one’s ever-changing self, rather than operating under the delusion that one is permanent, concrete, fully formed, and unchanging, allows one to take oneself less seriously, to see oneself as part of the flux of the universe, and to allow things to unfold as they will.

Part 3, Chapter 65 Summary: “Anger”

Kabat-Zinn recalls a time when his daughter’s look of pleading and embarrassment did not stop him from complaining to his daughter’s friend’s mother about that friend’s lateness to join them in the car. He recalls it to remind himself that he should have been present in the moment and that had he been more present he would have prioritized his daughter’s desire for him not to embarrass her over the expression of his anger and irritation, which solved nothing.

Part 3, Chapter 66 Summary: “Cat-Food Lessons”

Kabat-Zinn used to find it very triggering when the cat’s food bowl ended up in the sink with the human dishes; he found this an unhygienic practice, and then, once he aired his displeasure about it, he felt disrespected and ignored when his family continued to put the cat’s dishes in the sink with the human dishes.

He tuned into his anger in these moments, becoming aware of it rising in him. He would firstly feel revulsion and then anger. He noticed, while listening to his thoughts and observing his feelings, that his feelings of anger had to do with not being respected, listened to, or thought of by his family. He reflected that to his wife and daughters, putting the cat bowl in the sink was simply not a big deal, rather than an intentional slight of him. This allowed him to feel calmer.

In a “Try” activity, Kabat-Zinn recommends that readers tune into themselves in moments where things are making them angry; he encourages them to reflect on the phrase “making me angry.” It gives control to external forces rather than taking responsibility for one’s reaction. Furthermore, feelings can result from a creation of the situation in one’s mind’s eye, rather than being a complete view of the situation. Simply examining the reaction for a while, rather than immediately acting, can have positive impacts on a person’s understanding of the situation, as well as their outward expression of their feelings.

Part 3, Chapter 67 Summary: “Parenting as Practice”

Kabat-Zinn stopped attending meditation retreats once his children were born. He considered his children his “own private mindfulness trainer” that challenged him, exhausted him, and demanded constant selfless, loving kindness. The trials and tribulations of parenting are lessons in the importance of mindfulness; it is essential to view parenting as a challenging journey of self-improvement.

Both outer support and inner support are necessary to nourish oneself in this challenging task. Outer support takes the form of the love and support of one’s partner, friends, or family. Inner support comes from taking time to find stillness and presentness in oneself, in the form of mindfulness and meditation. Kabat-Zinn recalls meditating with his babies in his lap, feeling that they took on his relaxation and stillness as he monitored his breathing as well as their own. Parenting older children has created different challenges; Kabat-Zinn has had to confront and challenge many automated beliefs that have arisen in him. Furthermore, he has had to navigate the emotional challenge of having his children grow up and away from him.

In a “Try” exercise, Kabat-Zinn asks those who have children to observe them in silence and consider their needs. Often, an intuitive sense of what they need will arise.

Part 3, Chapter 68 Summary: “Parenting Two”

Kabat-Zinn explains that a parent is a major teacher in a child’s life, just as they are a major teacher in the parent’s life. He warns against using phrases like “my children,” as children are not a possession to be owned and molded to one’s will. He also warns against encouraging one’s children to meditate or urging them to do anything one is passionate about; instead, parents should lead by example, and children can choose their own path. Motivation for anything must come intrinsically from the child.

Part 3, Chapter 69 Summary: “Some Pitfalls Along the Path”

Kabat-Zinn warns against feeling pride and mastery of meditation; some days, one’s mind will be harder to silence, and the practice will be less successful. Furthermore, the ego should not be claiming meditation success. The meditator should remain humble and avoid “selfing.” On the other hand, meditators should avoid dwelling in negativity if their practice feels stale or boring. These feelings shouldn’t be inflated, but rather observed and accepted.

In a “Try” activity, Kabat-Zinn advises guarding against self-involvement or strong emotions by remaining mindful; all states of mind are valid and can be observed, and meditation has no particular aim of getting anywhere. Asking questions like “Am I using meditation as a technique?” and “Who is supposed to be getting somewhere?” can assist in remaining mindful, rather than becoming egotistical (170).

Part 3, Chapter 70 Summary: “Is Mindfulness Spiritual?”

Mindfulness can be considered inherently spiritual, as being completely present with the breath is being in appreciation of the majesty of all things. Furthermore, Kabat-Zinn muses that perhaps a feeling of spirituality simply means a feeling of oneness and “wholeness and interconnectedness” with all things (172). The spirit is often associated with the “breath of life,” and therefore the breath is associated in many spiritual beliefs with the conscience, the soul, and the holy (171). The gifts that breath can bring can be missed if the mind is elsewhere.

Although Kabat-Zinn acknowledges the way that meditation can be conceived of as an inherently spiritual practice, he avoids the word in his medical work, as it has such varied connotations depending on people’s belief systems. Instead, he refers to it as a “consciousness discipline” (171). Furthermore, he believes that meditation practice is beyond, or utterly outside of, thought and therefore difficult to label.

Kabat-Zinn also stresses that any labeling of meditation as spiritual should not imply that it allows one to transcend above the suffering, pain, and grittiness of life; rather, meditation is a willingness to sit and be with all things. It involves facing and sitting with fears and darkness, rather than avoiding these things.

Afterword Summary

In an Afterword (present in editions published after 2004), Kabat-Zinn speaks to the enduring popularity of his work; he believes that this is borne out of a desire for people to fully connect with who they really are and to live authentically and connectedly as this person. He feels that the work of mindfulness is even more necessary in our increasingly digitized world, which demands that we get even more done in even less time; we run the risk of never actually being present with ourselves. Inner wisdom has never been more necessary, and mindfulness helps us to reach this inner wisdom, clarity, and calm. Kabat-Zinn reminds readers that they are already perfect and that mindfulness is an invitation to see and sit with this perfection in its entirety, as well as to appreciate the oneness of the universe despite its nuance and multiplicity.

Part 3, Chapter 59-Afterword Analysis

In his final chapters, Kabat-Zinn continues to explore The Importance of Mindful Living; he provides information on further complimentary practices for the mindfulness journey, as well as warns against “selfing” and anger. He refers firstly to the Buddhist practices ahimsa and karma. Ahimsa entails “gentleness on yourself and in your life with others” (143). Intentionally limiting harm to self and others generates a more peaceful existence. It is associated with mindfulness, as harm is often borne out of fear; by facing and accepting our fears (which meditative practice encourages us to do), we are more likely to be able to treat ourselves and others with grace and kindness. As with many mindful principles, practicing ahimsa helps one to be mindful, and being mindful helps one to practice ahimsa.

The Importance of Mindful Living is also presented through the concept of karma, which refers to “an accumulation of tendencies that can lock us into particular behavior patterns, which themselves result in further accumulations of tendencies of a similar nature” (145). Only through mindful effort can we make choices about our karma, as mindfulness helps us to observe our impulses and decide if they are authentic and in line with the path we wish to travel on. On the other hand, living mindlessly leaves us “stuck in the momentum coming out of the past, with no clue to our own imprisonment, and no way out” (145). Kabat-Zinn expounds on the principles of karma with the intention that readers will have thoughts and behaviors inspired by understanding, clarity, and kindness, which are likely to bear fruit to further positive thoughts and behaviors; this is what it means to create, and therefore receive, positive karma.

Kabat-Zinn suggests that parenting is a fruitful path toward mindfulness practice, given its inherent challenges. A child can be understood as a

mindfulness teacher, parachuted into your life, whose presence and actions were guaranteed to push every button and challenge every belief and limit you had, giving you continual opportunities to see where you were attached to something and to let go of it (161).

Kabat-Zinn challenges the notion that there is no time for mindfulness as a parent, suggesting instead that practicing mindfulness allows one to manage the constant challenges and grow from them. He conveys the notion of self-development through parenting by using the metaphor of a mirror held up to the parent “that forces [them] to look at [them]self” (165). One’s flaws, frustrations, and mindlessness become apparent through one’s challenges as a parent. A willingness to learn through the process is essential: “If you can learn from what you observe, you just may have a chance to keep growing yourself” (165).

The Challenges and Benefits of Meditation are explored through the difficulty in achieving a feeling of oneness that acknowledges and accepts the diversity of the universe. Meditators should foster an appreciation for uniqueness and variety in the world even as they try to foster an appreciation of the unity among things. Kabat-Zinn uses the metaphor of the ocean to help readers to appreciate this concept: “The ocean is a whole, but it has countless waves, every one different from all the others” (151). The ocean is endlessly varying but also unified; this is a metaphor for the world more broadly, in terms of the variety of people, flora, fauna, landscapes, beliefs, and ways of being. We are all united even though we are so vastly different. Meditators should attempt to simultaneously internalize the seemingly contradictory notions of diversity and oneness.

Kabat-Zinn suggests that one can understand themselves and their place in the world better through meditation. He urges meditators to pose big questions of inquiry to themselves through meditation, but without expecting immediate answers. These big questions can center around self-identity, true purpose, and the meaning of life. By “carrying the wondering with you, letting it percolate, bubble, cook, ripen, come in and out of awareness,” answers, insights, or new directions might emerge (153). Above all, meditators should come to these questions with a spirit of curious and open-minded inquiry. However, Kabat-Zinn warns against “selfing,” which entails seeking internal stability through defining oneself in a fixed manner and then seeking validation of this constructed “self” through external rewards, material possessions, and adoration from others. This version of self tends to only feel good when “outside circumstances are supporting its belief in its own goodness” (156). On the other hand, it feels “bad when it runs into criticism, difficulties, and what it perceives as obstacles and defeats” (156). Only by becoming aware of the constructed nature of our identity process can we find more internal stability and move away from the need to be “propped up and reinforced” by “approval,” as constantly seeking assurance about our constructed self brings “no sense of enduring stability in one’s own being, nor calmness in the mind” (156).

Meditation, according to Kabat-Zinn, helps individuals to understand themselves in a way that moves away from anxiety and control and toward curiosity and acceptance. Kabat-Zinn recommends letting go of selfing impulses (i.e., the inherent need to define and understand oneself in fixed terms) and to instead just focus on being present in the moment. Letting go of the “elusive” notion of the “concrete, permanent, unchanging self” helps to “stop taking yourself so damn seriously,” as one can “escape the pressures of having the details of your personal life be central to the operating of the universe” (157). By accepting and embracing our own impermanence and un-fixedness, Kabat-Zinn asserts that one can find a measure of peace and release from the incessant anxiety of trying to control our surroundings; instead, “we accord the universe a little more room to make things happen” (157).

Lastly, in finishing his exploration of The Challenges and Benefits of Meditation, Kabat-Zinn attempts to address whether meditation is inherently spiritual. Meditation is difficult to define under any fixed view, as “mindfulness is beyond all thinking” (172). Having said this, Kabat-Zinn concedes that “waking up to vitality in every moment” may feel spiritual, or transcendent, for some (171). In viewing meditation in this way, he cautions against a “romantic yearning to transcend the pain, the suffering, and the responsibilities of this world of eachness and suchness, which includes the moist and the dark” (173). Instead, meditation sees and embraces the dark and the tragic as it aims to fully see all of life with honesty and clarity.

blurred text
blurred text
blurred text
blurred text